Scientists just measured something that sounds impossible. When light passes through atoms, it can spend what appears to be less than zero time interacting with them. Yes, negative time. And no, this isn’t science fiction.
Picture a stadium crowd doing the wave. People stand and sit in sequence, but somehow the wave moves faster than any single person.
Scientists at the University of Toronto found light doing something similar with atoms, except they measured the part where it got really weird.
Experiment that shouldn’t work
Light usually slows down when passing through materials. That’s normal physics.
But with very short light pulses and the right conditions, the peak of a light wave can exit a material before it seemingly should.
Scientists have seen this for years but dismissed it as a reshaping effect, not actual negative time. The Toronto researchers weren’t satisfied with that explanation.
They cooled rubidium atoms to near absolute zero and shot incredibly weak light pulses through them – so weak that they could track individual photons.
Aephraim Steinberg, a University of Toronto professor specializing in experimental quantum physics, led the work with researcher Daniela Angulo.
They used two laser beams. One carried the signal they wanted to study. The other acted like a heartbeat monitor for the atoms.
“This is tough stuff, even for us to talk about with other physicists. We get misunderstood all the time,” said Steinberg.
Measuring negative time
Here’s where things get strange. When a photon passed through and excited the atoms, the probe beam detected tiny changes.
These changes told them exactly how long the atoms remained excited. The answer? Sometimes it was negative.
“That time turned out to be negative,” Steinberg explained.
The team discovered that when light pulses experienced what physicists call negative group delay – when the pulse peak exits early – the atoms showed corresponding negative excitation times.
The two measurements matched perfectly, proving this wasn’t just a visual trick but a real physical phenomenon.
How negative time actually works
Before you start planning trips to yesterday, understand what’s really happening. The speed of light remains unchanged.
“We don’t want to say anything traveled backward in time,” Steinberg said. “That’s a misinterpretation.”
Light pulses contain many frequencies mixed together, like a chord in music. When these frequencies hit resonant atoms, each gets shifted slightly differently.
Mix them back together, and the peak can end up ahead of where you’d expect. No single part breaks the speed of light – the wave just reshapes itself through quantum interference.
The atoms essentially record this reshaping. When the pulse peak shifts forward, the atoms’ response shifts too, creating a measurable negative interaction time. It’s quantum mechanics at its strangest, but it follows all the rules.
Why scientists care
This experiment settles a long debate. Some physicists argued negative group delay was just mathematical sleight of hand. Others suspected it represented something physically real.
Their setup required extraordinary precision. They trapped rubidium-85 atoms in a tiny cloud, sending shaped signal pulses through it, while a probe beam traveled in the opposite direction.
The signal matched a specific atomic transition in rubidium. The probe stayed slightly detuned to monitor without being absorbed.
By correlating probe changes with single-photon detections, they isolated effects from individual photons.
Tests across different pulse durations and cloud densities confirmed their predictions every time. Where theory predicted negative delays, they measured negative times.
This discovery matters for quantum technology. Future quantum computers and networks need precise control of photon-atom interactions.
Understanding these timing effects, even negative ones, helps engineers build better quantum systems.
The work also pushes quantum mechanics into new territory. At quantum scales, particles behave in probabilistic ways that defy everyday intuition.
What happens next
This experiment shows that time measurements can get equally weird, though causality never breaks.
Steinberg acknowledged controversy around their findings, but noted that no scientist has challenged the experimental results.
“We’ve made our choice about what we think is a fruitful way to describe the results,” he said.
As for practical uses, Steinberg remains realistic.
“I’ll be honest, I don’t currently have a path from what we’ve been looking at toward applications,” he admitted. “We’re going to keep thinking about it, but I don’t want to get people’s hopes up.”
The discovery opens new paths for exploring quantum effects. Sometimes the strangest findings lead to unexpected breakthroughs.
We now know negative time isn’t just theoretical – it’s measurable, real, and perfectly consistent with physics. It is not the kind that lets you change the past.
The full study was published in the journal arXiv.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–