Deep in an underground, World War Two-era vault, investment manager Louis O’Connor guards his firm’s most valuable assets.
The treasure inside? Rare earth elements.
“Make no mistake about it, there’s three and a half meter walls and doors and armed security,” says O’Connor, the CEO of Strategic Metals Invest, a firm that lets individual investors buy into stockpiles of rare earths.
Many so-called rare earth elements are actually quite common, and they are mined globally, but China has a near-monopoly on refining them for use in everyday electronics, like speakers, as well as for crucial defense systems, like fighter jets.
When China decided to substantially cut off exports of seven types of rare earths this spring, O’Connor says he felt the pinch immediately. One investor touring the company’s vault at the time offered on the spot to buy O’Connor’s entire inventory of terbium and dysprosium, two valuable “heavy” rare earth elements, he says.
The episode illustrated the power of China’s dominance over the industry.
“They’re installing what you might call a tap system, where they can turn that tap on and off,” says O’Connor.
That supply chain chokehold has given China a powerful tool it has wielded in a trade war with the U.S. Within weeks of China requiring foreign companies to apply for a license to buy rare earths, several American and European companies said they were forced to shut down production lines. Regaining access to Chinese rare earths was a central point of contention in US-China trade negotiations this spring.
But China did not always enjoy such dominance. Developing an export control regime they could minutely control took decades of sometimes painful trial and error.
Spotting strategic value
During most of the 20th century, the U.S. was top dog in the rare earths industry, which was then-concentrated around the Mountain Pass mine in California.
China also recognized the strategic value of rare earths, and starting in the 1960s, Chinese executives came to visit Mountain Pass several times, says Mark Smith, a former CEO at Molycorp, a major rare earths processing company at the Mountain Pass mine.
“We toured them. We explained what we do, allowed them to take pictures and everything else. They took it back to China,” says Smith.
Chinese refineries then improved on technology, and taking advantage of cheap electricity in China, hundreds of lucrative mining and processing firms in the country popped up to service mostly domestic demand for rare earths.
But the industry was highly unregulated and chaotic, as hundreds of small-scale, private mines and refineries competed against one another, undercutting each other’s profits.
“They drive down the price against themselves,” says Chris Ruffle, an investor who has worked in China for decades, including in the metals industry. “They kill themselves.”
“China’s rare earths aren’t being sold at a ‘rare’ price but at an ‘earth’ price,” complained Xiao Yaqing, a minister of industry and information technology.
A dirty business
As Chinese producers sought an upper hand in rare earths, they also unleashed unrestrained mining that came at great cost to the country’s natural resources.
In the early 2000s, Ruffles visited a private rare earths refinery in Jiangsu, a province in southern China. “The thick smoke slightly gave it away,” says Ruffles of the facilities. He described huge piles of tailings — toxic, metallic by-products from other industrial processes, sitting on the bare ground.
Destructive, small-scale mining was especially prevalent in southern China, where the most valuable, natural deposits of “heavy” rare earth elements are.
“They would mine the side of the hill with their acts and picks and shovels, and then they would dig a hole in the ground, no liners or anything like that at all. Then they poured five gallon buckets of sulfuric acid or hydrochloric acid….let that certain stew for a while,” remember Smith, who frequently visited China during this period. “When the storms come in, all that acid just washes out.”
The mining left China’s terrain scarred with lasting groundwater and soil pollution. Local residents staged period protests against rare earth mining, but rare earth mining provided local governments with abundant revenue, and they repeatedly ignored central government orders to close down dirty mines.
“The rare earth industry has the profits of [selling] heroin but without the risks… Rare earth is more addictive than drugs,” wrote two Chinese state media reporters in a 2012 investigation into rare earths mining.
“There are generally two types of people who can deal with rare earths: the first is someone who has just been released from prison, and the other is someone who can get someone out of prison. Those who are not afraid of death and leading cadres are all involved,” in the journalists wrote.
Consolidation or bust
By the late 1990s, Beijing had had enough of the domestic price wars and local pollution. It started imposing production and export quotas to incentivize upstream processing of rare earths, cut down on pollution, and protect the industry from foreign intervention.
The quotas created two sets of prices, “in effect, two tier pricing, when exports were limited to the rest of the world that resulted in lower rare earth prices for domestic Chinese consumers,” says Rod Eggert, a professor of mineral economics at the Colorado School of Mines.
There was also a second, unintended consequence to the quotas: they creating a thriving smuggling industry. Up to a third of the country’s rare earth products in the mid-2000s was illegal, smuggled out of China despite state controls, analysts estimate, because of demand from Japan and the U.S.
Then, American and European companies cried foul over the export quotas, and in 2014, the World Trade Organization ruled China could not use them.
But China was unfazed. It was already shifting tactics. It would seek global dominance in rare earths not through controlling the volume of outputs, but instead, by controlling which firms could operate.
A “secret war” to consolidate
Authorities dubbed the campaign “one plus five:” an ambitious, and often ruthless, effort to winnow down the entire rare earth industry to just six consolidated companies. Authorities called the consolidation their “secret war” against illegal production.
Starting in 2011, provincial authorities were instructed to mount unannounced audits of mines, to seize contraband ore and byproducts, and when needed, dynamiting and smashing to pieces illegal mining operations.
“I saw firsthand how the private sector got squeezed out,” says Ruffle, the investor.
Within four years, China declared victory. It announced the closure of dozens of smaller mining and refining companies and guided the mergers of surviving companies into six supersized, mostly- state-owned firms, nicknamed the Big Six in China.
Through the Big Six, China could now largely control both supply and price.
“Whereas before you had a lot more competition from different producers, now you get very homogeneous pricing,” says Jan Giese, a Frankfurt-based rare earth trader. “It’s difficult to have competitive bids.”
American upstarts
Unlike metal commodities like nickel or gold, there is no independent exchange for buying and selling rare earth elements.
Because Chinese companies can cause huge price fluctuations depending on how much they decide to produce or export, investors have been wary of pouring money into new ventures in the U.S..
That has made raising capital to build refining plants a big challenge for American companies trying to break back into the industry.
“They’re putting their money into things like Alphabet and, you know, Amazon and, you know, all the high-flying type of investments and just very, very little, if any, is coming into the mining industry,” says Smith, the former CEO of Molycorp.
Some are still trying. Smith’s new venture, NioCorp, is opening new mines and refining capacity for rare earths in Nebraska.
Phoenix Tailings, in Massachusetts, is also among a handful of American companies prepared to refine rare earths, by refining the tailings, or leftover waste, from mining companies.
“We have to be full speed on the gas to make sure we’re successful here,” says Nicholas Myers, one of the co-founders and CEO.
The company already makes rare earth magnets for automotive and defense companies, and they are currently building a second plant in New Hampshire which the company says can meet about half of the U.S.’ defense needs for rare earth products.
For years, Myers said his company struggled to attract investment at the magnitude needed to compete with Chinese firms in scale.
This year, things changed, after China implemented a licensing system for foreign companies which caused rare earth exports to plummet.
“Definite tone shift,” says Myers, “I think what happened is the end customers, the folks at the big automotive companies or defense primes, realized that they had told their bosses that China would never shut off the supply for them.”
But this spring, China did shut off that supply.
The cut off galvanized American investor interest in rare earths, says Myers. Phoenix Tailings garnered a major round of investment in May, and now, for the first time in decades, the U.S. may make rare earth minerals again.
Aowen Cao contributed research from Beijing.
