Blog

  • Pakistan, Bangladesh express solidarity with Palestinian people – RADIO PAKISTAN

    1. Pakistan, Bangladesh express solidarity with Palestinian people  RADIO PAKISTAN
    2. Palestinian question a ‘test case’ for world, Dar tells UN moot on two-state solution  Dawn
    3. Pakistan reaffirms support for two-state solution at high-level UN Conference on Palestine  Ptv.com.pk
    4. Pakistan, BD vow to deepen bilateral ties  The Express Tribune
    5. Ikhtiar Wali applauds Ishaq Dar’s stand on Palestine, praises PML-N Leadership  Associated Press of Pakistan

    Continue Reading

  • US Squash Announces Partnership with InGenius Prep

    US Squash Announces Partnership with InGenius Prep

    PHILADELPHIA, July 28, 2025 – US Squash is proud to partner with InGenius Prep, the world’s premier college admissions consulting firm. This partnership will equip student-athletes and their families with expert support as they navigate the increasingly competitive path to top colleges and universities. New collaboration will provide US Squash families with expert guidance on navigating the college admissions process.

    Expert College Guidance for Student-Athletes

    InGenius Prep was founded on the simple observation that the most direct source of admissions knowledge comes from the people who worked inside the admissions office: former Admissions Officers. Their team of over 150 former Admissions Officers from every top school in the United States provides actionable insights that bolster students’ applications and increases their chances of admission by up to 10x.

    Comprehensive Programs That Set Students Apart

    InGenius Prep works with students from middle school through college application season, offering personalized support at every step of the journey. Their services help students identify and develop their academic and extracurricular strengths, build a compelling narrative and navigate the complexities of the admissions process with clarity and confidence. Whether families are looking for long-term planning or targeted application guidance, InGenius Prep provides expert strategy tailored to each student’s goals.

    Shared Commitment to Student Success

    “Forming this partnership with InGenius Prep ahead of the LA28 Olympic Games is an exciting milestone and an alignment of our shared missions,” said Dr. Kim Clearkin, Chief Program Officer at US Squash. “It’s a unique opportunity to strengthen both the academic and athletic pathways for our squash athletes. Through our shared commitment with the College Squash Association to grow the collegiate game, this collaboration creates real momentum for the future.”

    “We are so excited and honored to partner with US Squash. The work they do with, and for, squash players and their families is a perfect match for InGenius’ student-centered educational philosophy,” said Joel Butterly, CEO at InGenius Prep.

    InGenius Prep will be an event sponsor for select US Squash tournaments in 2025-26, including the 2025 U.S. Junior Open Squash Championships in Philadelphia from December 20-23 and the West Coast JCT in Fremont, California from October 11-13. At each tournament, their team will host presentations, interactive workshops and offer face-to-face consultations to help US Squash families navigate the college admissions process.

    Additionally, US Squash will co-host a series of webinars with InGenius Prep focused on topics relevant to student-athletes and college admissions. The first webinar will occur on August 14, 2025 at 6:00 pm ET.  Click here to register.

    About InGenius Prep

    InGenius Prep is the world’s premier college admissions consulting firm, officially recognized as the top consultancy in the U.S. Students who work with InGenius Prep are 7 times more likely to get into Top 10 schools and 8 times more likely to be admitted to the Ivy League. With a 99% overall acceptance rate and 97% of students admitted to their reach or target schools, InGenius Prep has helped thousands of students succeed in the highly competitive college admissions process. This includes student-athletes who have been accepted to Harvard, MIT, Cornell, Johns Hopkins, and other top universities.

    InGenius Prep is proud to be officially recognized as the country’s Top College Admissions Consultancy. For more information, please visit ingeniusprep.com.

    Continue Reading

  • Pakistan finance minister due in US for ‘final’ round of trade talks

    Pakistan finance minister due in US for ‘final’ round of trade talks

    Pakistan, Egypt resolve to boost cooperation in defense, trade and other key sectors


    ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s deputy prime minister and foreign minister, Ishaq Dar, and Egyptian FM Dr. Badr Abdelatty on Monday held a meeting in New York, where they agreed to strengthen bilateral cooperation in defense, trade and other key sectors, the Pakistani foreign ministry said.


    The meeting took place on the sidelines of a high-level United Nations (UN) summit on Palestine, which is being co-chaired by Saudi Arabia and France on July 28-29.


    Appreciating the continued collaboration at multilateral fora, FM Abdelatty congratulated Pakistan on assuming the Presidency of the UN Security Council for the month of July.


    “The two leaders emphasized the importance of enhancing broad-based cooperation across various sectors, including medical, minerals, defense, trade, and investment,” the Pakistan foreign ministry said.


    “They agreed on the need to strengthen connectivity between Pakistan and Egypt to promote economic integration and facilitate greater trade. Both sides also agreed to undertake high-level exchanges in the near future.”


    Pakistan and Egypt have cordial ties and both countries have resolved in recent years to facilitate businessmen with visas, exchange trade-related information and promote private-sector contacts.


    During Monday’s meeting, the two foreign ministers reiterated their unwavering support for the Palestinian people and their just cause, according to the Pakistani foreign ministry.


    “The two ministers underscored the urgent need for unimpaired humanitarian access, an immediate cessation of Israeli hostilities, and expressed hope for a meaningful and constructive outcome of the International Conference on the Two-State Solution,” it added.


    The UN conference is being held at a time of worsening humanitarian conditions in Gaza and France’s historic decision to formally recognize Palestine as a state.


    The summit takes place a day after Israel declared a “tactical pause” in fighting in parts of Gaza, where more than 57,000 Palestinians have been killed since October 2023, saying it would allow the UN and aid agencies to open secure land routes to tackle a deepening hunger crisis.


    Analysts say France’s move could tip the balance internationally. Already, 147 of 193 UN member states — nearly 75 percent — recognize Palestine, including nearly all of Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East. France would be the first G7 country to join that group, with the official declaration to be made at the UN General Assembly in September.

    Continue Reading

  • NASA Spaceline Current Awareness List #1,159 25 July 2025 (Space Life Science Research Results)

    NASA Spaceline Current Awareness List #1,159 25 July 2025 (Space Life Science Research Results)

    The abstract in PubMed or at the publisher’s site is linked when available and will open in a new window.

  • Barbero Barcenilla B, Rivero R, Lynch A, Cromer W, Gong J, Harandi B, Stegmann M, Le H, Lundine D, Chung M, Puig J, Mikhailova K, Coker H, Marks A, Gilbert R, Scott R, Barker R, Glowe P, Overbey EG, Mason CE.Feeding the cosmos: Tackling personalized space nutrition and the leaky gut challenge.npj Microgravity. 2025 Jul 18;11:45.PI: C.E. MasonNote: This article may be obtained online without charge.

    Journal Impact Factor: 5.1

    Funding: “This work was coordinated through the OSDR/Genelab Analysis Working Groups, as a collaboration across the Plant, ALSDA, and Human AWGs, as well as with BioAstra. We thank NASA OSDR for its continuous contributions in developing this research, as well as the Waypaver Foundation for their support. We also thank funding from WorldQuant, NASA (80NSSC22K0254, 80NSSC24K0728, 80NSSC24K1052) and the NIH (U54AG089334).”

  • Kumar K, Kumar S, Angdisen J, Datta K, Fornace AJ, Suman S.Radiation quality-dependent progressive increase in oxidative DNA damage and intestinal tumorigenesis in Apc1638N/+ mice.Curr Oncol. 2025 Jul 1;32(7):382.PIs: A.J. Fornace, S. SumanNote: This article is part of Section “Gastrointestinal Oncology” (https://www.mdpi.com/journal/curroncol/sections/Gastrointestinal_Oncology) and may be obtained online without charge.

    Journal Impact Factor: 3.4

    Funding: “This research was funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), grant number NNX15AI21G (PI: Albert J. Fornace, Jr.), 80NSSC22K1279 (PI: Albert J. Fornace, Jr.), and 80NSSC24K0287 (PI: Shubhankar Suman). We acknowledge the Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Shared Resources, which is supported by NCI grant number P30CA051008 (PI: Louis Weiner).”

  • Zakharyan R, Hakobyan S, Brojakowska A, Bisserier M, Zhang S, Khlgatian MK, Rai AK, Davitavyan S, Stepanyan A, Sirunyan T, Khachatryan G, Sahoo S, Garikipati VNS, Arakelyan A, Goukassian DA.The effects of space radiation on the transcriptome of heart right ventricle tissue.npj Microgravity. 2025 Jul 21;11:46.PI: D.A. GoukassianNote: This article may be obtained online without charge.

    Journal Impact Factor: 5.1

    Funding: “The authors would like to acknowledge the support of Peter Guida, MaryAnn Petry, and their staff on the NASA support team at the Biology Department and BLAF animal facility at Brookhaven National Laboratory for their help with our longitudinal mouse lifetime studies. We would also like to acknowledge Adam Rusek and the NSRL operations team for their support in our particle radiation studies. This work was funded by the NASA Human Research Program, grant No: 80NSSC19K1079 (formerly, 80NSSC18K0921) and grant No: 80NSSC21K0549 (PI – Kenneth Walsh, DAG – subcontract) to D.A.G. and the ADVANCE Research Grant funded by the Foundation for Armenian Science and Technology and Research Grant 25FAST-1F004 funded by the Higher Education and Science Committee of the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sport of the Republic of Armenia. This study was also supported by the National Institutes of Health/National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NIH/NHLBI) under grants K01HL159038-01A1 and R25HL146166 (to MB), the American Heart Association Career Development Award (24CDA1269532 to MB), and the American Thoracic Society Research Program (Grant No. 23-24U1 to MB). …”

  • Fettrow T, Stephens C, Prinzel L, Holbrook J, Ballard K, Bastami S, Stewart M, Kiggins D.Human contributions to safety data testbed flight simulation study: Data methods, processing, and quality.Sci Data. 2025 Jul 16;12(1):1247.Note: This article is a Perspective and may be obtained online without charge.

    Journal Impact Factor: 5.1

    Funding: L.J. Rothschild is affiliated with NASA Ames Research Center.

Continue Reading

  • Near-Earth Asteroid 2025 OW close encounter: an image – 27 July 2025

    Near-Earth Asteroid 2025 OW close encounter: an image – 27 July 2025

    We captured the near-Earth Asteroid 2025 OW while it was safely approaching for its 28 July 2025 flyby with the Earth. It will come as close as 633.000 km from the center of the Earth, 1.6X times the average distance of the Moon.

    Near-Earth Asteroid 2025 OW: 27 July 2025.

    The image above comes from a single 300-second exposure, remotely taken with the “Elena” (PlaneWave 17″ + Paramount MEII + SBIG STL-6303E)  robotic unit  available as part of the Virtual Telescope Project and installed in Manciano, under the darkest skies of the Italian peninsula. The telescope tracked the fast apparent motion of the asteroid, this is why it looks like a sharp dot of light in the center (indicated by an arrow),  with stars leaving long, bright streaks on the background.

    At the observing time, asteroid 2025 OW was at about 1.9 million km from our telescope, still safely approaching to the Earth.

    This (51 – 110) meters asteroid will reach its minimum distance (about 633.000 km from the center of the Earth.) from us on 28 July 2025, at 19:44 UTC (source: Nasa/JPL). Of course, there were no risks at all for our planet.

    Back to “Solar System” page

    Support The Virtual Telescope Project!

    Support us! Please, donate and receive an EXCLUSIVE image of the stunning COMET C/2023 A3 Tsuchinshan-ATLAS and much more, specifically made for supporters like you!

    Continue Reading

  • Fossil teeth reveal dinosaur diet clues

    Fossil teeth reveal dinosaur diet clues



    You are what you eat, it turns out—even if your last meal was 150 million years ago, according to new research.

    While the grub itself may be long gone, a record of dinosaurs’ favorite foods has been stowed away in their ancient tooth enamel over the last eon.

    “It’s really just more proof that this ecosystem was as spectacular as we thought it was.”

    When researchers at The University of Texas at Austin took a close look, they discovered that some dinosaurs were discerning eaters, with different species preferring different plant parts.

    Tooth enamel contains calcium isotopes that reflect the range of foods the dinosaurs ate; different types of plants have different chemical signatures, and discrete parts of trees—from buds to bark—can also have unique signatures.

    According to the study’s lead author Liam Norris, the results help explain how so many behemoth creatures all lived together in the same area at the same time.

    “The ecosystem that I studied has been a mystery for a long time because it has these giant herbivores all coexisting,” says Norris, a recent doctoral graduate at UT’s Jackson School of Geosciences.

    “The idea is that they were all eating different things, and now we have found proof of that.”

    The findings appear in Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology.

    Norris inspected teeth from four dinosaur species and one crocodyliform, both herbivores and carnivores, that roamed the Western US during the Late Jurassic. The plant-eaters are the long-necked Camarasaurus; the short-armed Camptosaurus; and the trunk-legged Diplodocus. The meat-eaters are the bipedal Allosaurus and the comparatively small, crocodile-like Eutretauranosuchus.

    The bones and teeth of these ancient creatures were all found in the Carnegie Quarry deposit in northeast Utah, which is thought to have formed during an extreme drought in as little as six months to a few thousand years.

    “We were very lucky to be able to study fossils of dinosaurs that lived together and were all rapidly preserved in a single deposit,” says Rowan Martindale, an associate professor at the Jackson School’s earth and planetary sciences department.

    “The Jurassic tomb preserved a unique paleontological gem and these skeletons are beautifully displayed at Dinosaur National Monument.”

    Norris, who now works at the Texas Science & Natural History Museum, studied teeth from 17 individual animals across these five species. The specimens were loaned by the Utah Field House of Natural History State Park Museum or accessed in the field at Dinosaur National Monument. He shaved off a dusting of their enamel, which he took back to the Jackson School for calcium isotope analysis. Jackson School Professor John Lassiter and Radiogenic Isotope Laboratory Manager Aaron Satkoski, both coauthors on the paper, helped to analyze and interpret these data.

    Previously, scientists believed that large herbivorous dinosaurs coexisted by munching on different levels of the tree canopy according to height. However, Norris’s research shows that plant height wasn’t the only factor driving the differentiation of their diets—instead, it was specific plant parts.

    For example, Norris found that the Camptosaurus was a rather discerning eater, preferring softer, more nutritious plant parts such as leaves and buds. The Camarasaurus ate mostly conifers, with a preference for woody plant tissues. The Diplodocus ate more of a mixed diet that included soft ferns and horsetail plants lower to the ground, as well as tougher plant parts.

    “This differentiation in diet makes sense with what we see from the morphology of these animals: the different height, the different snout shape. Then, we bring in this geochemical data, which is a very concrete piece of evidence to add to that pot,” Norris says.

    This research also provides interesting food for thought to a theory about long-necked dinosaurs having flexible necks that could be used to reach many areas of vegetation without having to expend the energy to move the rest of their body. This research, which shows that the dinosaurs ate from different levels of the tree canopy, furthers that line of thinking.

    The carnivores in the study—the Allosaurus and Eutretauranosuchus—had an overlap in calcium isotope values, which could mean that they ate some of the same things. However, the results also showed that the Eutretauranosuchus is more likely to have eaten fish, while the Allosaurus primarily ate herbivorous dinosaurs—possibly including the three other dinosaur species mentioned in this study.

    For this ancient ecosystem to have supported so many enormous dinosaurs with such specific dietary proclivities helps to paint a picture of the vegetation and plant productivity of the time.

    “It’s really just more proof that this ecosystem was as spectacular as we thought it was,” Norris says.

    Henry Fricke of Colorado College also coauthored the study.

    Source: UT Austin

    Continue Reading

  • What if 10,000 steps per day was never the magic number? Bombshell scientific study says you need far less for health benefits

    What if 10,000 steps per day was never the magic number? Bombshell scientific study says you need far less for health benefits

    Are you a step-checker? Do you look at your phone, watch, or other activity tracker a few times a day, to see if you’ve hit the 10,000 steps mark yet? Do you feel guilty if your step count doesn’t ever get over, say, 7,000?

    What if the 10,000-steps-per-day mark was just a publicity campaign from the 1960s that caught the public’s attention, and recent science indicates that 7,000 is the true mark that carries a health benefit with it? That is exactly the scenario that’s playing out.

    The latest large-scale analysis, published in The Lancet Public Health and drawing from over 160,000 adults across 57 studies worldwide, challenges the fabled 10,000-step mark. Researchers not only concluded that walking 7,000 steps per day was in fact linked to dramatic improvements in longevity and protection against a wide array of diseases, but that going the extra 3,000 steps didn’t make that much of a difference after all.

    Why 10,000 steps became ‘the goal’

    For years, “10,000 steps” has been consecrated as the gold standard of daily fitness. But the origin of that benchmark wasn’t medical—it was marketing. Ahead of the 1964 Tokyo Olympics, a Japanese pedometer called the “manpo-kei,” which translates to “10,000-step meter,” launched a global fitness trend. That catchy round number stuck, becoming the default goal for millions using wearable trackers.

    The 10,000 steps benchmark just seems to be one of those things that lodges in your head. Popular YouTubers and fitness influencers run “10,000 step challenges” encouraging followers to meet or exceed the daily target, often featuring “walk with me” workout sessions. It’s been granted official status by digital apps, with the number “10,000” now a default setting on devices such as Fitbit. Corporate wellness programs, social media challenges, and public health campaigns also routinely use the 10,000-step mark as a motivational goal and badge of accomplishment.

    The bombshell findings

    The new research poured cold water on the idea of 10,000 as a scientific minimum. Compared to the least active group (2,000 steps), those who managed 7,000 steps per day saw:

    • 47% decreased risk of premature death
    • 25% lower chance of cardiovascular disease
    • 38% reduced risk of dementia
    • 6% lower cancer risk
    • 22% lower incidence of depressive symptoms
    • 28% reduction in falls
    • 14% lower risk of developing Type 2 diabetes

    What’s more, these massive benefits approached a plateau with 7,000 steps; walking all the way to 10,000 steps per day generated only small additional reductions in risk for most conditions. For some diseases—like heart disease—benefits increased slightly beyond 7,000, but for many others, the curve flattened.

    “Although 10,000 steps per day can still be a viable target for those who are more active,” according to the abstract, “7,000 steps per day is associated with clinically meaningful improvements in health outcomes and might be a more realistic and achievable target for some.” The authors add that the findings should be interpreted in light of limitations, such as the small number of studies available for most outcomes, a lack of age-specific analysis and potential biases at the individual study level.

    ‘More is better’—but only up to a point

    Walking more remains beneficial, particularly for those who are mostly sedentary. The study found the greatest jump in health benefits when moving from very low step counts (~2,000) up to 7,000 daily. For the general adult population, 7,000 steps—about three miles—delivers the bulk of the effect. For adults over 60, benefits plateau a bit earlier, around 6,000–8,000 steps, while younger adults may see the curve level off closer to 8,000–10,000.

    The researchers also revealed that the pace of walking was far less important: just getting in the steps, regardless of speed, provided the protective benefits.

    Rethinking the fitness message

    This research could prompt a shake-up in public health messaging, which has long promoted aspirational but somewhat arbitrary targets. Fitness professionals and wearable device makers now have fresh evidence to advise clients and consumers that a daily goal of 7,000 is both realistic and powerfully protective. Then again, 10,000 steps is catchy.

    For this story, Fortune used generative AI to help with an initial draft. An editor verified the accuracy of the information before publishing. 

    Continue Reading

  • Israeli rights groups accuse Israel of genocide in Gaza

    Israeli rights groups accuse Israel of genocide in Gaza

    Emir Nader

    BBC News, Jerusalem

    Reuters Israeli human rights groups B'Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights-Israel hold a news conference in occupied East Jerusalem to release reports accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza (28 July 2025)Reuters

    B’Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights-Israel presented the findings at a news conference in Jerusalem

    Two leading Israeli rights organisations have said Israel’s conduct in the war in Gaza constitutes genocide against the Palestinian population.

    B’Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights-Israel released separate reports on Monday based on studies of the past 21 months of conflict.

    The organisations, which have been active in Israel for decades, said in a joint statement that “in these dark times it is especially important to call things by their name”, while “calling on this crime to stop immediately”.

    An Israeli government spokesman said it strongly rejected the accusations of genocide, which are the first to be made by human rights groups based in Israel.

    “Our defence forces target terrorists and never civilians. Hamas is responsible for the suffering in Gaza,” David Mencer said.

    At a news conference in Jerusalem on Monday, B’Tselem’s executive director Yuli Novak said her organisation’s report was “one that we never imagined we would have to write”.

    The 88-page document states: “An examination of Israel’s policy in the Gaza Strip and its horrific outcomes, together with statements by senior Israeli politicians and military commanders about the goals of the attack, leads us to the unequivocal conclusion that Israel is taking co-ordinated action to intentionally destroy Palestinian society in the Gaza Strip.”

    In its 65-page report, Physicians for Human Rights Israel (PHRI) said its health-focused legal analysis found that Israel had targeted Gaza’s healthcare infrastructure “in a manner that is both calculated and systematic”.

    “The evidence shows a deliberate and systematic dismantling of Gaza’s health and life-sustaining systems – through targeted attacks on hospitals, obstruction of medical aid and evacuations, and the killing and detention of healthcare personnel,” the report said.

    Dr Guy Shalev, executive director of PHRI, said: “Silence in the face of genocide is not an option. We want to stress: confronting genocide is not only the responsibility of legal and political institutions. Confronting it demands urgent action from the global health community.”

    The organisations found the “horrific and criminal Hamas attack” on Israel on 7 October 2023 was a triggering event that caused fear and collective trauma among Israelis.

    However, in its response to the attack, they alleged, Israel’s government had pursued a campaign based on the “promotion of extremist ideologies and the dehumanisation of Palestinians in Gaza”.

    They said this was a reference to language used from political and military leaders to soldiers fighting on the ground, which labelled all Palestinians in Gaza as being responsible.

    PHRI concluded that the acts it identified were “not incidental to war but part of a deliberate policy targeting Palestinians as a group”, and in a manner that fulfilled at least three acts defined in Article II of the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, to which Israel is a signatory.

    Reuters File photo showing Palestinians evacuating Kamal Adwan hospital in Beit Lahia, northern Gaza, during an Israeli offensive (21 May 2024)Reuters

    Only 18 of Gaza’s 36 hospitals are still partially functional, according to the UN (file photo)

    A number of international rights organisations, UN human rights experts, and scholars have accused Israel of committing a genocide in Gaza.

    The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is also examining a case brought by South Africa alleging that Israeli forces are committing genocide against the Palestinians in Gaza.

    Israel has vehemently denied the allegation and has called the case “wholly unfounded” and based on “biased and false claims”.

    Dr Shalev told the BBC that PHRI and B’Tselem were concerned that the organisations and their staff might be subjected to verbal or physical violence in Israel in response to their reports.

    “But we are hoping that people will listen to what we are saying,” he added.

    Yuli Novak of B’Tselem said the process at arriving at the conclusion that Israel was conducting a genocide had been fraught.

    “To really understand that your country, your collective, is actually committing genocide, that is a very hard mental and personal process,” she said.

    “It breaks something very basic in your understanding about who we are.”

    Israel launched its war in Gaza in retaliation for Hamas’s 7 October 2023 attack, which killed about 1,200 people and led to 251 others being taken hostage.

    Israeli attacks have since killed more than 59,900 people in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run health ministry. The ministry’s figures are quoted by the UN and others as the most reliable source of statistics available on casualties.

    Continue Reading

  • ‘We do not support this retraction’

    ‘We do not support this retraction’

    When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.

    The retracted paper claimed that arsenic-based life had been discovered in California’s Mono Lake. | Credit: NASA

    The controversial claim of microbes that exhibit arsenic rather than phosphorus in their biochemistry has been retracted by the journal Science 15 years after it was first published — but while most in the research community are pleased by the decision, the retraction has angered the authors of the original study.

    Arsenic, as we know from its use as a poison, is a toxic substance. Thus, life as we know it of course would not include arsenic in its biochemistry. Yet, because the search for alien life is, by its very definition, a search for life as we dont know it, astrobiologists like to consider the possibility of organisms that have a different biochemistry to the one we’re familiar with.

    This, in fact, led to NASA, — and with great razzamatazz, one might add — holding a press conference in 2010 that declared the supposed discovery of arsenic-based microbial life in Mono Lake, which is a heavily salt-rich body of water in California.

    NASA claimed this discovery would forever change the search for life beyond Earth.

    Life’s chemical details

    Consider that all life as we know it, including human life, exclusively uses six key elements in its biochemistry: carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, phosphorus, oxygen and sulfur.

    Take phosphorus as an example. In our biochemistry, phosphorus, in the form of phosphate, is crucial for forming the sugar-phosphate backbone of molecules of RNA and DNA, as well as storing and delivering metabolic energy through adenosine triphosphate (ATP).

    Astronomical observations, however, suggest phosphorus might not be evenly distributed across the Milky Way galaxy. And it has been posited that life in those phosphorus-depleted regions of space might survive by substituting phosphorus with another element, such as arsenic. It was this possibility that, 15 years ago, prompted a team led by Felisa Wolfe–Simon of NASA’s Astrobiology Institute to search for possible arsenic-based life in the extreme alkaline conditions within Mono Lake.

    Then, in that 2010 press conference, the discovery team revealed they had found it in the form of a bacterium known as GFAJ-1 present in supposedly phosphorus-free samples from Mono Lake. The discovery was hailed as a revolutionary development in astrobiology — for all of about five minutes.

    Despite all the hullaballoo of the press conference, when Wolfe–Simon and her team’s work was published online by the journal Science, other biochemists quickly came out to argue there were serious flaws in the research. Specifically, they argued that swapping out phosphorus for arsenic would cause DNA to dissolve within a second when exposed to water. More damning was the claim from the critics that the samples used by Wolfe–Simon’s team were contaminated by phosphorus from the lake. The life in those samples, the critics argued, was probably still just using the phosphorus within those samples.

    When Science finally published the research paper in print a year later, it was appended by eight technical comments from other researchers highly critical of the findings, plus two extra papers from independent teams who tried to replicate the results but failed to find any evidence for arsenic-based life in Mono Lake. Wolfe–Simon and her colleague also published a response to the criticisms, in which they wrote that “we maintain that our interpretation of As [arsenic] substitution, based on multiple congruent lines of evidence, is viable.”

    Not many people believed them, and Wolfe–Simon’s team have never published the results of any follow-up experiments that try to address some of the points in the criticism; they also declined to respond to any criticism other than through the medium of peer-reviewed letters. The blowback against Wolfe–Simon’s team was fierce and, at times, unsightly, with some abusive comments being leveled directly at Wolfe–Simon, who was still a young researcher. As a consequence, Wolfe–Simon opted to drop out of active research.

    Now, 15 years later, Science’s Editor-in-Chief Holden Thorp and the journal’s Executive Editor Valda Vinson have reopened the can of worms by deciding to retract the paper. Why has it taken so long for them to do so?

    “Science did not retract the paper in 2012 because at that time, Retractions were reserved for the Editor-in-Chief to alert readers about data manipulation or for authors to provide information about post-publication issues,” Science’s editors wrote in their official retraction notification. “Our decision then was based on the editors’ view that there was no deliberate fraud or misconduct on the part of the authors. We maintain this view, but Science’s standards for retracting papers have expanded. If the editors determine that a paper’s reported experiments do not support its key conclusions, even if no fraud or manipulation occurred, a Retraction is considered appropriate.”

    A black and white image of several bacteria under a microscope.

    Transmission electron micrograph shows a strain of the bacterium called GFAJ-1, which researchers claimed can incorporate arsenic into its DNA and other vital molecules, in place of the usual phosphorus. | Credit: Science/AAAS

    The other side of the story

    Traditionally, papers were only retracted if evidence of fraud or misconduct came to light, or if a paper’s authors requested that it be retracted, perhaps if new evidence disproved their results. However, the Retraction Watch website reports that, since 2019, Science has retracted 20 papers from its various publications, mostly on the basis of what the journal believes to be innocent errors.

    Suffice to say, Wolfe–Simon and her team-members do not agree with Science’s decision. In their response, published in the interests of fairness along with the retraction by Science, the team stated their disappointment.

    “We do not support this retraction,” they wrote. “While our work could have been written and discussed more carefully, we stand by the data as reported. These data were peer-reviewed, openly debated in the literature, and stimulated productive research.”

    Moreover, the team argues that Science’s decision-making process was flawed and that it contravenes the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics, or COPE. Those guidelines state that retraction is only warranted when there is clear evidence of major errors, the fabrication of data, or falsification that damages the reliability of a paper’s findings.

    “In going beyond COPE, the editors of Science explain that ‘standards for retracting papers have expanded’,” the team wrote. “We disagree with this standard, which extends beyond matters of research integrity. Disputes about the conclusions of papers, including how well they are supported by the available evidence, are a normal part of the process of science. Scientific understanding evolves through that process, often unexpectedly, sometimes over decades. Claims should be made, tested, challenged, and ultimately judged on the scientific merits by the scientific community itself.”

    Thorp and Vinson went further in a blog post on Science’s website, where they were clearer on the reason for the retraction and arguing that COPE’s guidelines allow them to retract the paper. “Given the evidence that the results were based on contamination, Science believes that the key conclusion of the paper is based on flawed data,” they said.

    The Retraction Watch website reports that Wolfe–Simon’s team said that when they had been told about the retraction, they were not told that it was because of the claimed contamination. In fact, they only heard that from a second-hand source who had seen the blog post. Even so, contamination had been the number one criticism going all the way back to 2010, and was not a new or surprising accusation.

    Thorp and Vinson ended their blog post by saying “we hope this decision brings the story to a close.”

    RELATED STORIES

    — Bad news for alien life? Earth-size planets may be less common than we thought

    — Did we actually find signs of alien life on K2-18b? ‘We should expect some false alarms and this may be one’

    — Is the bar higher for scientific claims of alien life?

    It remains to be seen whether this will be the case. However, what is clear is that there are serious lessons to be learned by both sides about how to present controversial results and how to both give and receive scientific criticism — Thorp and Vinson made a point in saying they condemn verbal abuse and ad hominem attacks that had been directed towards Wolfe–Simon and her team by other researchers. It also sheds light on the intricacies of when and how papers should be retracted.

    In recent years, we have seen how claims of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus and dimethyl sulphide, which is a potential biosignature, in the atmosphere of the exoplanet K2-18b have sparked debate and argument. It is to be hoped that scientists in the research community can remember to not take disagreements too far when debating these and other claimed discoveries in the future.

    Continue Reading

  • A Panchromatic Characterization Of The Evening And Morning Atmosphere Of WASP-107 b

    A Panchromatic Characterization Of The Evening And Morning Atmosphere Of WASP-107 b

    Spatial distributions of MnS (left) and Na2S (right) clouds as a function of longitude, averaged over all latitudes, and pressure in our cloudy SPARC/MITgcm model. The color mapping represents the mass mixing ratio of the cloud particle, with the same scaling in each panel. — astro-ph.EP

    Limb-resolved transmission spectroscopy has the potential to transform our understanding of exoplanetary atmospheres. By separately measuring the transmission spectra of the evening and morning limbs, these atmospheric regions can be individually characterized, shedding light into the global distribution and transport of key atmospheric properties from transit observations alone.

    In this work, we follow up the recent detection of limb asymmetry on the exoplanet WASP-107 b (Murphy et al. 2024) by reanalyzing literature observations of WASP-107 b using all of JWST’s science instruments (NIRISS, NIRCam, NIRSpec, and MIRI) to measure its limb transmission spectra from ∼1-12 μm.

    We confirm the evening–morning temperature difference inferred previously and find that it is qualitatively consistent with predictions from global circulation models. We find evidence for evening–morning variation in SO2 and CO2 abundance, and significant cloud coverage only on WASP-107 b’s morning limb.

    We find that the NIRISS and NIRSpec observations are potentially contaminated by occulted starspots, which we leverage to investigate stellar contamination’s impact on limb asymmetry measurements.

    We find that starspot crossings can significantly bias the inferred evening and morning transmission spectra depending on when they occur during the transit, and develop a simple correction model which successfully brings these instruments’ spectra into agreement with the uncontaminated observations.

    A Panchromatic Characterization Of The Evening And Morning Atmosphere Of WASP-107 b: Composition and Cloud Variations, and Insight into the Effect of Stellar Contamination

    Matthew M. Murphy, Thomas G. Beatty, Everett Schlawin, Taylor J. Bell, Michael Radica, Thomas D. Kennedy, Nishil Mehta, Luis Welbanks, Michael R. Line, Vivien Parmentier, Thomas P. Greene, Sagnick Mukherjee, Jonathan J. Fortney, Kazumasa Ohno, Lindsey Wiser, Kenneth Arnold, Emily Rauscher, Isaac R. Edelman, Marcia J. Rieke

    Comments: Currently under review with the Astronomical Journal. Comments welcome
    Subjects: Earth and Planetary Astrophysics (astro-ph.EP)
    Cite as: arXiv:2505.13602 [astro-ph.EP] (or arXiv:2505.13602v1 [astro-ph.EP] for this version)
    https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2505.13602
    Focus to learn more
    Journal reference: AJ 170 61 (2025)
    Related DOI:
    https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-3881/addf38
    Focus to learn more
    Submission history
    From: Matthew Murphy
    [v1] Mon, 19 May 2025 18:00:03 UTC (6,001 KB)
    https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.13602
    Astrobiology,

    Continue Reading